How do utilities score a contractor's safety record?

Most utilities look at three numbers: your workers' comp experience mod (EMR), your total recordable incident rate (TRIR) and your DART rate. The mod compares your claims with the expected losses for businesses with your class codes and payroll. TRIR and DART come from your OSHA 300 log. Each utility sets its own cutoffs.

Reviewed by Michael Schaeffer
Updated November 2026

When a utility needs extra crews after a storm, it usually calls contractors already approved on its vendor list. Getting on that list means passing a safety review, and the review often starts with a handful of numbers on a form.

Those numbers move slowly and lag behind the work. A rough year can cost you bids for several years, and storm overtime can shift your rates in ways you might not expect. Knowing how each number is built gives you time to act before the next review.

Where contractors get caught

One bad year that hangs around

The experience mod draws on about three policy years of data and skips the most recent one. A serious claim may not show up right away, and once it does, it can weigh on your mod for three straight ratings. That delay catches a lot of owners off guard.

Small claims that add up

The mod formula weighs how often claims happen more heavily than how big they are. A string of minor medical claims from one crew can move your number more than a single serious injury. Fast reporting and a return-to-work program help keep minor injuries minor.

Paperwork errors that inflate your mod

Payroll placed in the wrong class code, or reserves left open on claims that already closed, can push your mod above what your record deserves. These mistakes can usually be corrected, but corrections take time, so the worksheet needs a look well before it becomes final.

Rates that swing with hours

TRIR and DART are figured per hour worked. At a small company, one or two recordable cases can post a high rate in a single year, while heavy storm overtime raises hours and changes the math. Reviewers often look at several years together for that reason.

How are EMR, TRIR and DART different?

The experience mod is set by a rating bureau from your workers' comp claims and payroll. A mod of 1.00 is the baseline. Below it is a credit and above it is a debit, and the mod is multiplied against your premium, so the same figure that screens you also prices your comp.

TRIR and DART are figures you work out yourself from your OSHA 300 log. The BLS formula multiplies the number of cases by 200,000, which equals 100 full-time employees working a year, then divides by the hours your employees actually worked. TRIR counts every recordable case. DART counts only cases that caused days away from work, restricted duty or a move to another job.

You can run your own numbers with the free TRIR and DART calculator from TAKKEL Insurance, then compare them with what each utility's prequalification form asks for.

What can you do before the next review?

Your mod worksheet is not final until the rating bureau publishes it. That window is where most of the useful work happens.

For a deeper walk-through, read how the experience mod is calculated and which mistakes tend to push it up.

  • Get the draft worksheet early and check each claim against your loss runs.
  • Ask the adjuster to close resolved claims and release stale reserves.
  • Confirm payroll sits in the right class codes, such as line work versus tree trimming.
  • Make sure every sub carried valid workers' comp so their injuries stay off your policy.
  • Keep your OSHA 300 log accurate, since the rates are only as good as the records.
  • Plan bids and vendor approvals around the date the new mod takes effect.

What to have ready

  • Experience mod worksheets for the last three years
  • Loss runs from each workers' comp carrier
  • OSHA 300 logs and 300A summaries for recent calendar years
  • Total hours worked by year, overtime included
  • Your written safety program and training records
  • Each utility's prequalification cutoffs for EMR, TRIR and DART

If your mod is keeping you off a bid list, TAKKEL Insurance can review the worksheet and loss runs with you and show what is driving it.

Get a plan to lower your mod

Frequently asked questions

What EMR do utilities accept?

There is no single cutoff. A mod of 1.00 is the baseline and lower is better, but each utility, co-op and prime contractor sets its own maximum in prequalification. Check the vendor portal or bid documents for the exact number, and ask whether a variance with a written explanation is possible if you sit just above it.

How long does a bad claim stay in my mod?

A claim counts as long as its policy year sits inside the experience period, which usually spans three policy years and leaves out the most recent one. So a claim can appear later than you expect and then affect several ratings in a row. Accurate reserves help keep it from counting for more than it should.

What is the difference between TRIR and DART?

Both come from your OSHA 300 log and use the same formula. TRIR counts every recordable injury or illness. DART counts only the cases that led to days away from work, restricted duty or a job transfer. Utilities often ask for both because together they show how often people get hurt and how serious it was.

Can a low EMR alone get me through prequalification?

Not always. Many utilities read the mod, TRIR and DART side by side, along with training records and your written safety program. A good mod paired with a rising recordable rate can still prompt questions, so be ready to explain the trend behind each number and what you changed after any incident.

This guide is provided with TAKKEL Insurance, an independent commercial agency that works with multiple carriers and focuses on utility contractors.

Reviewed by Michael Schaeffer, licensed insurance agent, TAKKEL Insurance. Updated November 2026.

Sources