P-type vs. N-type solar panels

Key takeaways

• N-type solar panels offer advantages in efficiency compared to P-type panels.

• Solar panels with N-type modules are more resistant to degradation than those with P-type modules.

• Despite their higher cost, N-type solar panels can often be a better value over time due to increased energy savings.

If you could gamble on which type of solar technology is likely to boom in the coming years, N-type solar panels would be a smart bet. Advantages in efficiency and longevity have drawn the attention of solar manufacturers and researchers, with many directing their efforts and budgets towards N-type technology.

In this article, we explain what N-type solar panels are, how they work, and how they differ from P-type solar panels and other technologies. You’ll also learn about the advantages and disadvantages of N-type solar panels and why their higher price point shouldn’t necessarily scare you away.

P-type vs. N-type solar panels: Overview

Residential solar panels generate electricity through the photovoltaic (PV) effect—a reaction in which sunlight absorbed by silicon wafers stimulates electron activity, generating an electrical current. Silicon in its pure form is not an especially good conductor. That’s where the N-type and P-type layers come in.

The photovoltaic cell layer is made by placing a neutral silicon layer between one negatively charged (N-type) and one positively charged (P-type) layer. These layers are created by doping the silicon with different elements. Doping with phosphorus adds electrons to create a negative charge for the N-type layer, and boron doping leaves an electron deficiency, resulting in a positive charge.

This imbalance encourages electrons to jump from one side to the other when sunlight is absorbed in the solar panel. That movement creates the direct current (DC) electricity that passes to the solar inverter, which turns it into the alternating current (AC) energy that is eventually used to power your home.

How photovoltaic cells work in N-type and P-type solar panels

Both N-type and P-type solar panels produce the same end result, but through different means. The table below shows a head-to-head comparison of how each type functions.

Advantages of N-type solar panels in modern energy systems

N-type solar panels are gaining attention in the solar industry for their technical advantages and potential to shape the future of renewable energy. 

Researchers and manufacturers see these panels as a promising evolution in photovoltaic technology, driven by their unique material properties. N-type panels use a different doping process that results in fewer performance-limiting defects and improved stability under harsh conditions. These features set them apart from conventional P-type panels and contribute to long-term reliability.

Key advantages of N-type solar panels include:

• Higher solar efficiency potential: N-type cells typically convert more sunlight into electricity, increasing total system output.

• Lower defect density: These panels have fewer impurities in the silicon, which means less energy loss during operation.

• Better temperature tolerance: N-type panels maintain higher efficiency even in hot weather, making them well-suited for diverse climates.

• Longer lifespan: With greater resistance to light-induced degradation, N-type modules often deliver consistent performance over many years.

Efficiency comparison: N-type solar panels vs. P-type modules

The efficiency difference between P-type and N-type solar panels is driven by their semiconductor properties. 

N-type panels generally achieve higher conversion efficiency because they have fewer defects in the silicon, which means less energy is lost as heat or through recombination. P-type panels, made with boron-doped silicon, are more prone to impurities and light-induced degradation, which lowers their long-term output. 

In most cases, N-type panels outperform P-type panels by 1-2 percentage points, making them more attractive for installations where maximizing energy generation per square foot is a priority.

The efficiency advantage of N-type modules typically increases over time. N-type solar panels are less prone to degradation and efficiency loss than P-type panels. That means that P-type panels will become less solar efficient more quickly than N-type panels.

Why N-type solar panels resist degradation over time

Two main types of degradation occur in solar panels, causing them to lose efficiency over the years. N-type panels tend to be more resistant to both.

Light-induced degradation (LID)

In P-type solar modules, light exposure exacerbates boron-oxygen defects in the silicon. These defects reduce the PV layer’s ability to convert sunlight into energy, causing a 1% to 3% solar efficiency loss in the first few days. Since N-type panels don’t use boron, they are practically immune to the effects of LID.

Potential-induced degradation (PID)

The other main type of degradation that affects solar panels is PID. This occurs when a voltage difference between the semiconductors in the panel and the surrounding materials results in ion migration and electricity leakage. N-type panels are also more resistant to PID than P-type panels, giving them yet another longevity advantage.

Which solar cell technologies use P-type and N-type structures?

While N-type panels appear to be the direction in which the solar industry is moving, P-type solar panels still have their applications. Their lower price point and still-reasonable efficiency mean they’re still a viable option for certain uses.

The technologies that use these different https://poweroutage.us/solar/solar-technology/panel-types">types of solar panels include:

• N-type: Roof installations with space constraints, building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPV) like solar shingles, high-energy yield projects, off-grid solar setups

• P-type: Residential and commercial installations with budget constraints, lower energy requirement projects

How N-type solar panels are shaping current market trends

Thanks to the advantages they offer, major players in the solar industry have shifted their development and manufacturing focus to N-type panels. Companies like LONGi, Jinko, Panasonic, and REC are a few examples of manufacturers that have invested heavily in the production of N-type products.

This shift is happening at multiple levels. Not only are high-performance residential systems pivoting to N-type solar panels, but utility companies are also employing N-type technology at a large scale as well. 

When to choose P-type or N-type solar panels for installations

N-type solar panels offer clear advantages over P-type panels that make them a better choice for most applications. Budget is the main reason why you would elect to go with P-type panels instead.

However, even though P-type panels currently have a lower price tag than N-type panels, that cost difference could disappear over time due to the increased energy savings N-type panels can deliver. Especially when you consider that the efficiency gap between the two types will only grow over time.

Bottom line on N-type solar panels

N-type solar panels offer substantial benefits for homeowners and others looking to invest in solar energy. They are more efficient and last longer than P-type solar panels. Unless your budget rules out N-type solar panels as an option for you, they tend to be the better choice for most applications. N-type solar technology also has an exciting future ahead that’s worth keeping an eye on.

FAQ about N-type solar panels

Below are a few frequently asked questions about N-type solar panels:

What are N-type solar panels?

N-type solar panels are photovoltaic modules built with silicon doped using phosphorus to create negatively charged carriers. These panels deliver higher efficiency, superior temperature performance, and greater resistance to common degradation effects compared to traditional p-type solar modules.

What are the disadvantages of N-type solar panels?

The main disadvantage of N-type solar panels is cost. N-type panels still have a higher price tag than other types of panels, which can make N-type solar panels a poor choice for some homeowners.

Which solar panel is best, P-type or N-type?

N-type solar panels are better than P-type panels for most applications due to their superior efficiency and longevity. P-type panels may be better in situations where budget takes priority over energy output.

Are N-type solar panels worth it?

N-type solar panels are typically worth the additional expense due to their better solar efficiency and resistance to degradation. These properties mean that you’ll likely get greater energy savings with N-type panels, which could negate the initial cost difference or even make N-type panels overall cheaper in the long run.

What are the components in an N-type solar panel setup?

In addition to the panels themselves, N-type solar energy systems require a solar charge controller, a solar inverter, and other supplemental equipment.